I am unfortunately not
aware of any single reliable source of information like you have requested.
However, I can provide a few observations/suggestions that I hope might
* Be cautious about reviews, and maintain a "healthy
mistrust". It is good to keep in mind that the reviews are only as reliable as
the reviewers, which oftentimes is not at all reliable. For example, it is clear
that some popular "Catholic" movie reviews have been downright scandalous –
sadly even including movie reviews appearing on diocesan sites. You might
be quite surprised (even shocked) at what they have considered acceptable
viewing. As a parent, you should be aware of this fact. Also, the nature of the
list must be considered (e.g. are they trying to sell you something?, is it
faithfully Catholic?). One tip: If they recommend books like Harry Potter, this
is NOT a good sign...
Potter hides the signature of the king of the darkness, the devil" (Chief
Exorcist of Rome, Father Gabriele Amorth)
"It is good,
that you enlighten people about Harry Potter, because those are subtle
seductions, which act unnoticed and by this deeply distort Christianity in the
soul, before it can grow properly" (Cardinal Ratzinger, the future Pope Benedict
more information, try 'Critic Suggests Demonic Influence in Blockbuster Works'
* When looking for suitable materials for purchase (e.g.
movies, books), it has
been my experience that a good method is first to look at the offerings of
trusted publishers (e.g. those with a strong reputation for faithfulness). You
may find the caliber of their offerings is superior to less trusted publishers.
* Typically, older publications (e.g. before the 1960's)
may be "safer". Unfortunately, a fair number of "contemporary" publications may
contain questionable to overtly unsuitable material. The good news is that many
older publications are available to download online for free.
* Avoid "updated versions" of traditional materials. In
certain cases, the changes may "destroy" the work.
* For ideas for suitable materials in various subjects, you
might contact traditional Catholic homeschooling group(s) and ask if they have
reading recommendations. However, be certain they are fully orthodox (small 'o')
and be cautious about situations where they may have a financial interest in
* When I have had requests in the past for information
about certain books/authors, it didn't take me long to find serious problems
with them by simply scanning online customer reviews. Of course one must use
caution with these reviews, but some may still prove beneficial.
* Be on guard against
modernism, as it may affect 'a lot' of Catholic media today.
* With the state of things in the world today, it
unfortunately can be quite a challenge to find materials free from offensive
content. That is why many faithful Catholics stick with traditional reading
materials. As applicable, I generally prefer to focus on older materials with
imprimaturs and good authors – especially books by saints and other holy
persons. There is only so much time, so why waste it on unworthy books?
* Ultimately, there is really no substitute for
reading/watching the item yourself (of course this would be done *after*
diligent research indicates that the material is appropriate), even though this might prove somewhat time-consuming. Nevertheless it is important for parents to take all manner of
precautions to protect their dear ones.
Finally, you might be
interested in some quotes from popes & saints regarding activities & reading.
They can be helpful for gaining perspective on what types of things might be
suitable. For example, consider these reflections... (click links to view)
Quotes Re: Movies, TV, Recreation
Quotes Re: Reading Materials
I am sorry I wasn't
able to provide the specific information you were looking for, but I hope
something above might still be of some assistance.
Reminder: We make no guarantee whatsoever regarding any item herein. Items herein may be the opinions of their authors and do not necessarily reflect our views.
All applicable items may be subject to change at any time without notice. Utilize any link(s) appearing on this page at your own risk.
For more terms information, see "Important Notice" below.