Things You May Or May Not Know About Pope Paul VI /
Was He A Bad Pope?
By: Pat
|
Summary: Facts About Pope Paul VI: Was Paul VI A Bad Pope?
Keywords: Pope, Supreme Pontiff,
Pontificate, Papacy, Pope Paul VI, Pope Paul 6, Pope Paul the
Sixth, Giovanni Battista Montini, Second Vatican Council,
Canonization, Saint, 'Pope St. Paul VI', Modernism, Ecumenism, Ecumenical, Leadership, Authority, Inaction, Poor Formation, Heresy, Religious Indifferentism, Changes in the Church, Liberalism, Revolution, Bad Pope, Worst
Pope |
All Catholics in the 21st century are STILL being
significantly affected by the actions of the 20th
century Pope Paul VI. Born in 1897, Giovanni Battista
Montini oversaw about 3/4 of the
Second Vatican
Council until its conclusion in 1965. He was -
controversially - canonized in 2018 by the likewise
controversial
Pope Francis I. Considering his enduring
impact on the Church as a whole and on the lives of
individual Catholics in particular, it seems pertinent
to highlight relevant aspects concerning the person of
Pope Paul VI and of his 15 year papacy. How history
will ultimately judge his pontificate remains to be
seen, but the almost 50 years since his death are
already rife with consequences plain for all to see.
At the outset, let me say frankly that I don't think
Montini should ever have been made pope. He was
doctrinally suspect, ill/frail since childhood, poorly
formed, and too weak to lead. His unsuitability to
take on the papacy was noted by his friend Jean
Guitton...
"Paul VI did not have the makings of a pope. He did
not have that which is characteristic of a pope:
resolve, the strength of resolve."
And...
"With him one was not in the presence of a cleric, but
of a layman who seemed to have been suddenly elevated
to the papacy."
Yet, Paul VI took hold of the office of the papacy in
1963, just a few months shy of his 66th birthday. Numerically, it is difficult to ignore... Pope Paul
the 6th, in his 60's, reigning in the 1960's. I won't
assert that there is any significance to these
numbers, but I nevertheless find them interesting.
[No, I am NOT claiming that Paul VI is associated with the
mark of the beast (Apoc. 13:18). I am merely pointing
out the numbers for those who might
find such details to be of interest, especially since Pope
Paul VI himself claimed seven messages he gave were
'as the seven trumpets of the Apocalypse' (those
trumpets, of course, preceded earthly catastrophes).]
And I will also say candidly from the start that I
consider his 'canonization' to be both scandalous and
unwarranted. It seems to me to be a political maneuver
to 'canonize' the revolutionary Second Vatican
Council. Thankfully, I do not believe that
canonizations are
infallible, especially if they are
conducted to serve a purpose other than truly
ascertaining a person's holiness & honoring God.
Edited by the respected author
Peter Kwasniewski, the book "Are Canonizations
Infallible?" [Amazon Associates link
here] includes a collection of relevant essays
on this topic from various writers that may lend
support to my view. And given several of the more
recent canonizations, I think it is safe to say that
canonizations do *not* fall under the limited
protection of infallibility [for more on this subject,
try
here and
here]. Besides, even the 'miracles' that were
credited to Pope Paul VI in his canonization process
may be doubtful (e.g. reduced quantity, 'miracles
failed to meet traditional standards', haste, 'lack of
rigorous scrutiny', medical intervention vs.
miraculous intervention). It has been claimed, for
example, that Paul VI's alleged 'miracles' would not
have received a favorable determination if subjected
to the scrutiny used at Lourdes. Even if the alleged
'miracles' were not questionable, there are
nevertheless plenty of historical facts in the public
record that do not at all support his canonization.
[And no, I am not 'attacking' the man personally - my
focus is primarily on the job he did as
the Supreme Pontiff, Vicar of Christ.]
Before proceeding any further, there are a few things
to note. First, all items below are to the best of my
knowledge true, however I can't really vouch for them
personally as I was not yet alive at the time Paul VI
became Pope in 1963. Second, for any quotes I've used,
I may have altered the order, added or excluded
emphasis, and combined paragraphs together. Third,
items below may be in any order.
And fourth, I acknowledge that I have relied on the
'definitive' bio of P6 by Yves Chiron, "Paul VI: The
Divided Pope" [Amazon Associates link
here], as well as other sources for the
material herein.
Let's begin with the things you 'might have known' or
'probably know'...
* Pope Paul VI closed the
Second Vatican Council ("the
'French Revolution' in the Church")
* Pope Paul VI presided over
unparalleled &
revolutionary changes in the Church, the so-called
"aggiornamento"
* Pope Paul VI presided over unprecedented changes to
the Mass ("the Mass was changed beyond recognition"),
resulting in a
Protestantized new rite that was
created with the assistance of Protestant advisors
* Pope Paul VI famously lamented that the "smoke of
Satan" had entered into the temple of God
* The revolutionary changes put Pope Paul VI at odds
with
Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre (but Pope Paul VI did
NOT excommunicate Lefebvre)
In fairness, he did do a few good things...
* Pope Paul VI defended the indissolubility of
marriage (shockingly 'undone' by
Pope Francis)
* Pope Paul VI defended
priestly celibacy
* Pope Paul VI rejected the use of
contraceptives
* Pope Paul VI rejected changes to the
Holy Rosary
(regrettably,
some 'optional' changes were made by
Pope John Paul II)
Yet are not Paul VI's 'good things' about the least
we should expect from the Vicar of Christ, a man under
the protection of the Holy Spirit? Yet, half of the
four 'good things' listed above have been 'undone' by
his successors, another is often disregarded, and the
remaining is continually under attack. While Pope Paul
VI cannot be directly blamed for actions of other
popes, his papacy did help create the climate
favorable for his successors to act as they did.
Now some things you might not have known about Pope
Paul VI...
* He was ill since he was a child. From the
biography
referenced earlier...
"Of a weak constitution, he gave signs that his health
would always be fragile. Sickness would mark all of
his childhood and youth."
* He had an unusual seminary formation ("he was
excused from the majority of the required priestly
formation on grounds of poor health"). Again, I quote
the above referenced biography...
"In truth he was never an ordinary seminarian. The
bishop of Brescia and the rector of the seminary
exceptionally allowed him not to undergo the usual
seminary life by boarding there; his parents made it
clear that the state of his health could not take it.
It is, therefore, as a day-student that he attended
classes, in ordinary street clothes. But soon enough
he was not able even to come to seminary."
"His status remained ambivalent. Everyone among his
friends knew that he was preparing for the priesthood,
yet he still declined to take up the cassock; right up
until a few months before his ordination, he continued
to sign his published articles as 'G. B. M., Student.'
He lacked the strength to survive twenty hours of
classes at the seminary every week, but somehow still
had enough energy to participate actively in La Fiona
and in the activities of the Manzoni Association, and
also to give catechism lessons to future first
communicants. Finally, part of his time was
consecrated to his priestly formation—–a very
scattered formation."
"[D]igesting all that information was beyond his
strength. Thus, he prepared himself for the priesthood
alone at home, with the assistance of various clergy.
To be ordained a priest without having undergone a
seminary formation was, at the time, extraordinary. In
the intellectual, moral, and religious formation of
Montini, the fact is of great importance. He did not
receive the
Scholastic education which then formed the
basis of ecclesiastical learning. Nor did he have any
experience of community life, which instills certain
lifelong rules, disciplines, and habits; nor had he
experienced the separation from the world which years
of seminary firmly fixed into one's being."
* His reception of minor and major orders was
reportedly "accelerated" thanks to his important
relative (The "haste was perhaps the bishop of
Breseia's favor to an important citizen's son who
could not follow the traditional formation at the
seminary.")
* He was allegedly "emotional, fickle, and uncertain
in his judgements", but also "easy to like, very
sincere, very open, and yet inscrutable."
* While having a 'fondness for France', he could
apparently speak French and 8 other languages (Latin,
Italian, Spanish, English, Portuguese, German, Greek,
Hebrew), being fluent in several.
* It is alleged that Pope Pius XII began to "distrust"
Montini. According to the
above referenced biography...
"[Pope Pius XII] understood that it was his duty to
prevent Montini from becoming pope."
The above was related by Pope Paul VI's friend Jean
Guitton.
* Before becoming
Pope, he was accused of 'thwarting
Rome' by his actions. Per the
above referenced biography...
"When he could, he still tried to thwart some Roman
decisions. Thus, when Fr de Lubac wanted to have his
work Mysière de l'Eglise translated, and the vicariate
of Rome refused to grant the imprimatur because the
author was then under a cloud of suspicion, Archbishop
Montini granted the imprimatur himself and allowed the
translation to be printed in Milan. He cited the book
repeatedly in his discourses and, on occasion,
distributed copies to priests of his diocese."
* His health affected his work. According to the
bio referenced above...
"Throughout much of the year 1935, Msgr. Montini was
absent from Rome, for health reasons. In January, he
contracted a severe influenza, which led to
complications and kept him away from the Secretariat
of State until August."
"At the beginning of March, he tried to go back to
work at the Secretariat of State but, after a check-up
and an X-ray, his doctor, who also diagnosed a
generalized asthenia, recommended complete rest."
"The magnitude of his duties, but also his
inexperience in managing the diocese, not to mention
his fragile health, obliged him to appoint two
supplementary auxiliary bishops."
* His election as Pope may have been tied to
'strategizing' by liberals. As noted in his
bio...
"Cardinal Montini remained in his own diocese of Milan
until June 16, when he travelled to Rome. He then went
to Frascati, to the south of Rome, where, on the 17th,
he held a private meeting with five other
cardinals—–Liénart, Frings, Suenens, König, and
Alfrink—–all of them leaders of the extreme
"progressive" tendency in the Council. What was
decided there we do not know, but on the following
day, the 18th, the five other cardinals held a meeting
in the utmost secrecy, with several more, at nearby
Grottaferrata. This meeting had been called by
Cardinal Lercaro of Bologna, a prelate who since the
election of John XXIII had shown himself the most
ostentatious progressive in the Italian hierarchy. At
Grottaferrata the cardinals agreed on a strategy to
work for the election of Lercaro himself, or, if that
failed, of Montini. To complete the details, the
meeting was held in the house of Cardinal Lercaro's
secular factotum, the banker Umberto Ortolani, who was
later revealed to be a prominent Freemason, and who
was sentenced to nine years in prison for the
fraudulent bankruptcy of the Banco Ambrosiano."
* As Pope Paul VI, he...
* Presided over the Protestantization of Mass (the
Novus Ordo) & other
sacraments
* Effectively stripped the sacred
liturgy of its
sacred language,
Latin
* Suppressed the Leonine prayers after
Mass (they may
still be said in tradition-minded parishes)
* Suppressed the subdiaconate & minor orders (they are
still used in traditional orders)
* Suppressed the Index of Forbidden Books
* Abrogated the
Oath Against Modernism
* Revised the rite of exorcism, including "significant
changes from the traditional practices", for which he
himself said, "I do not know why we have shortened
exorcisms: I am not sure that it was very realistic or
fitting."
* Refused to do the consecration of Russia to the
Immaculate Heart of
Mary, as requested at
Fatima, even
though hundreds of bishops implored him to do it (Pope
Paul VI also reportedly refused a private meeting with
the still-living seer of Fatima, Sr. Lucy)
* Opposed attributing the appropriate title
'Mediatrix' to the Blessed Virgin Mary, supposedly
judging the truthful & worthy title "inopportune and
even harmful"
* Created a new 'permanent' synod of bishops, which
even today seems ready to wreck future havoc on the
Church
* Reformed the (formerly conservative) Curia on his
own initiative ("the most astonishing, most daring,
most rigorously premeditated project and major
historical decision of Paul VI, without which what was
to follow would not have been possible")
* Changed the rules for papal elections (a.k.a.
plotting/scheming?) so that wise elderly - and
probably more traditional - cardinals could not
participate in papal elections (his friend Jean
Guitton supposed that he made this change "to diminish
the weight of traditionalist cardinals in the next
election")
* Opened the cause of beatification for his
predecessor, John XXIII, who convened the Second
Vatican Council
* Pope Paul VI 'overturned' the allegedly conservative
plan of Pope John XXIII for Vatican II. According to
the Forward of Paul VI's
bio...
"On the doctrinal side, Paul began the damage by
overturning the conservative plan John XXIII had for
his Council, throwing its direction into the hands of
a few Western European hierarchies, and allowing
Modernist heresy to take control, led by
self-promoting Council periti. The result, soon seen
throughout the Church, was the attack on the most
basic tenets of belief, the corruption of the
seminaries, and the emergence of a race of renegade
priests, by whom the faith of the worldwide laity was
ruined. On the liturgical side, Paul VI's work was to
hand over the task of 'reform' to a clique of
revolutionaries and to produce a gutted travesty of
Christian worship. Catholics today blame Francis for
revoking the toleration of the old Mass granted by
Benedict XVI, but it was Paul VI who destroyed it in
the first place and with a totalitarianism more complete
than what we are seeing now."
* Pope Paul VI engaged in various 'dramatic gestures'
that would generally be considered appalling &
offensive to good Catholics. For example...
* He abandoned the papal tiara, an apparent
"renunciation of the temporal power that this triple
crown represented". (As one critic stated, "Those who
witnessed with bewilderment the theatrical and
populist laying aside of the papal tiara, or the
undignified embraces exchanged by Paul VI [and
schismatics/heretics]... will recall the disconsolate
expression of poor Cardinal Ottaviani; he, like us,
must have been convinced of the paradoxical and
unprecedented subversion of the Papacy being carried
out by the Pope himself.")
* He gave a relic (the very head of St. Andrew!) to
the schismatic Orthodox.
* He gave his pastoral ring - a symbol of authority -
to the supposed 'Archbishop' of Canterbury (a layman
lacking valid orders), who put the ring on his own
finger.
* He returned the flag from Lepanto to the Muslims
(the miraculous victory at Lepanto was credited to Our
Lady of the Rosary in the 16th century battle that
"saved Europe from Muslims").
The above four items seem symbolic of his entire
papacy: an ecumenical surrender.
* Pope Paul VI fostered religious
indifferentism by
promoting false
ecumenism - by the items above and
also through actions such as kneeling before the
schismatic metropolitan in the Sistine Chapel and
kissing his feet, by asking a
Protestant layman to
'bless' people along with him, and by sitting near a
schismatic 'Orthodox' leader in "exactly identical
seats to mark their (so-called) equality." In fact it
was stated in his bio that...
"[H]e spontaneously declared that ecumenism was 'the
most mysterious and important enterprise of my
pontifical ministry'"
And his biographer notes that...
"If there is one area where the last years of Paul
VI's reign appeared almost as enthusiastic as the
first, it was ecumenism"
One critic speaks of Paul VI's 'chief obsession':
"ecumenism at any price".
* Regarding his fondness for ecumenism, it was a
driver of the Protestantizing of the Mass. According
to his friend, Jean Guitton...
"Paul VI had the ecumenical intention to remove, or at
least to underplay anything in the Mass which might be
too Catholic in the traditional sense of the word, in
order to draw the Catholic Mass closer to the
[heretical] Calvinist [service]."
He did, in fact, realize his intention by overseeing
the Protestantization of the Mass and other
sacramental rites in order to please those outside the
Church (recall that the fierce heretic & enemy of the
Church, Martin Luther, said: "Let us destroy the Mass
and we shall have destroyed the Church"). These
revisions to the Mass under Paul VI were carried out
by a suspected
Freemason. Note that: 1-Freemasons are
'enemies of the Church', and 2-Protestants are
heretics who reject the Real Presence of Christ in the
Holy Eucharist. In stark contrast to the
Traditional
Latin Mass, Paul VI's Mass has been so Protestantized
that various Protestants have said they can now use
the same prayers as Catholics for their (heretical)
'services' and certain Protestants have approved of
their members receiving Holy Communion in
Catholic
churches! [Note: This is of course a very serious
matter in light of 1 Cor. 11:27-29: "Therefore whoever
eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord
unworthily will have to answer for the body and blood
of the Lord. A person should examine himself, and so
eat the bread and drink the cup. For anyone who eats
and drinks without discerning the body, eats and
drinks judgment on himself."]
* Pope Paul VI scandalized Catholics by his
man-centeredness. From the
above referenced biography...
"This same December 7, Paul VI gave a final message to
the Council which was about to end. Over the four
years of the Council, the Church had been very
occupied with man, 'man as he truly presents himself
in our era, living man, man entirely occupied with
himself, man who makes himself not only the center of
all that interests him, but who dares to think himself
the principle and reason behind every reality - tragic
man, the victim of his own drama; a man who is both
sinner and saint.' The pope continued: 'The old story
of the Samaritan has been the model of the Council's
spirituality. A sympathy without limits has entirely
invaded it. ... We also, We more than anyone, We hold
the cult of man.' The expression was shocking and even
scandalous."
* Rather than having questionable documents properly
corrected, Pope Paul VI may have simply ordered a note
to be appended without changing anything in the
documents themselves.
* Pope Paul VI may have been 'effectively surrounded
by Masons' and modernists, who 'guided him in
the most important decisions of his pontificate'.
According to critics, Pope Paul VI was "a long-time
friend of the neo-modernists" and he "did all that was
in his power to promote the progressivist agenda by
removing all of the obstacles in its way. Thus,
whether by action or by omission, he effectively
abandoned the primacy of the Faith, of pontifical
authority, of Jesus Christ, and of the Church. The
great evil of the pontificate of Paul VI was that he
consistently refused his primary duty: to feed the
flock and preserve the deposit of faith."
* Pope Paul VI was a 'divided Pope'. As his
bio
states...
"That the same pope was able to publish two solemn
texts of such different tones and spirits in the space
of a few months shows how far there were two mindsets
that coexisted in him, or even two personalities: one
was religious, traditional, and quick to defend the
great truths of dogma, as well as Church discipline;
the other was humanist, sociopolitical, and
innovative."
* Besides distorting the Catholic Mass 'beyond
recognition', Pope Paul VI commissioned the deformed
("disturbing, ugly") bent crucifix of Lello Scorzelli
that John Paul II often carried. He also commissioned
the 'unsettling, serpent-like' Paul VI Audience Hall
with its 'ugly, hideous' statue.
* He furthermore had a fallacious sense of reality and lapsed
into 'unreality'. As his
bio states...
"Despite the great concern he had expressed throughout
the year 1965 [and despite alarming 'facts on the
ground' (see below
for some examples)], Paul VI was confident. In his
interview with Corriere della Sera in October he had
affirmed: "Besides the crisis of faith in the world,
there is not, happily, a crisis of the Church."
And as Romano Amerio's book,
Iota Unum [Amazon Associates link
here], notes...
"[H]is tendency to lapse into unreality led Pope Paul
to mistake the products of his own imagining for the
reality of the world around."
* He could also seriously misread things. For example,
his bio quotes Pope Paul VI as follows...
"The lifegiving breath of the Spirit has come to
awaken in the Church her sleeping energy, to rouse
dormant charisms."
Whereas in reality, the Church would undergo "pockets
of collapse." (Cardinal Pell)
Likewise the following quote is attributed to Pope
Paul VI...
"Whoever sees in the Council a relaxation of the prior
teachings of the Church, towards her faith, her
tradition, her asceticism, her charity, her spirit of
sacrifice, and her adhesion to the Word and the Cross
of Christ, or worse still, an indulgent concession to
the fragility and fluid, relativistic mentality of a
world without principles and without any transcendent
purpose - a sort of convenient, undemanding
Christianity- will be making a serious mistake."
Regarding this last quote, we can only wish he
was right. However, facts demonstrate that he was
terribly mistaken.
* He arguably put his failings on others (e.g.
Archbishop Lefebvre, who was NOT 'excommunicated' at
the time and was responding to the revolutionary
changes made under Pope Paul VI's watch). According to
his bio, Paul VI ironically declared...
"[I]f there is later a schism, it is not I who will be
responsible for it, but the insane and now morbid
obstinacy of Archbishop Lefebvre, who is tearing apart
and scandalizing the Church by his disobedience."
Yet it was precisely obedience to Pope Paul VI and his
'frenzy of change' that was scandalizing and tearing
apart the Church!
And he further insulted Archbishop Lefebvre and called
him the 'thorn of his papacy'...
"He is a lost soldier. ... He belongs in a psychiatric
hospital.... He is the thorn of my papacy."
Yet, it was Pope Paul VI who was mistaken about
Archbishop Lefebvre (e.g. Paul VI wrongly thinking
the Archbishop made his seminarians take an oath
against the Pope).
* He also reportedly insulted good Catholics who
lamented over the loss of the universal & precious,
sacred
Latin language in the Mass, ironically claiming
that critics of the vernacular...
"do not show a true devotion or an authentic sense of
the significance and value of the Mass, but rather a
certain spiritual sloth which makes them refuse the
personal effort of understanding and participation"
* He famously wept when he realized he had been deceived.
I will paraphrase an account of the event as
follows...
"The V2 conservatives brought information to Pope Paul
VI showing that modernist elements had manipulated the
drafting process during the council. This realization
'deeply' affected him, leading him to weep."
* Paul VI also had to make admissions such as...
"the opening to the world has become a veritable
invasion of the Church by worldly thinking. We have
perhaps been too weak and imprudent."
And...
"the smoke of Satan has entered the temple of God"
And...
"Perhaps we were wrong to abolish the exorcisms ]in
the rite of baptism]"
And...
"Vocations are diminishing, and cohesion and the
spirit of conquest are growing weak among the laity
itself—a feeling of uncertainty is running through the
Church's body like a shudder"
* Pope Paul VI's poor formation & poor theology was
made evident in certain assertions. For example, he
claimed that the pastoral Second Vatican Council was
'greater' than the Council of Nicaea (or Nicæa/Nicea), a council that
dogmatically affirmed the divinity of Christ. As
stated in his bio...
"That same day Paul VI sent him a letter confirming
the sanctions imposed in May and commanding him to
accept the texts of the Second Vatican Council and the
subsequent reforms. Vatican II 'holds no less
authority than that of the Council of Nicaea, and
under certain aspects is even greater,' affirmed the
pope. The Council of Nicaea in 325 had condemned the
heresy of Arius, dogmatically affirmed the divinity of
Christ, and defined the 'Symbol of Nicaea,' that is to
say the first part of the Credo. The comparison was
audacious and scandalized the traditionalists.
Cardinal Villot himself, who knew about this letter
before it was sent, criticized the comparison because
the Second Vatican Council had not, as did Nicaea,
promulgated dogmas, but was intended simply to be
pastoral. Paul VI, however, insisted on maintaining
this comparison because he did not want to lessen the
importance of Vatican II and thus minimize the gravity
of Archbishop Lefebvre's opposition."
* Pope Paul VI could be benevolent to those on the
left, "magnanimous beyond measure" with priests who
wanted to be relieved of their priestly functions, yet
authoritarian towards Catholics who held to tradition.
His bio notes...
"In his papacy, we see a strange dichotomy between his
authoritarian attitude toward those who could be
grouped as conservatives and his endless benevolence
and patience with those on the 'left.'"
* His bio also claims his spirituality was 'emotional
and immature'...
"As to his spirituality, his notes and letters show it
to be emotional and immature. The glaring lack of
solid theological foundation to his spiritual life
assuredly goes back to the absence of a seminarian's
normal spiritual formation."
* Pope Paul VI survived at least one assassination
attempt (it occurred in the Philippines).
* Pope Paul VI reportedly considered resigning. From his
bio...
"The doctrines contrary to the faith that were
circulated by theologians, the challenges from priests
and the faithful, and the criticisms from part of the
hierarchy continued to try his strength until they
threatened to overwhelm him. His moral trials were
aggravated by the physical decline due to old age (he
was racked with arthritis through the 1970s). At the
approach of his seventy-fifth year, persistent rumors
grew that the pope might resign. According to Jean
Guitton, Paul VI seriously considered this
possibility."
When evaluating the papacy of Pope Paul VI, we should
keep in mind a number of things. For example...
* The Pope has the duty - the OBLIGATION, in fact - to
pass on what he's received, not to change things.
* The Pope has no right to attack faithful Catholics
because they are behaving as faithful Catholics.
* The Pope had no right to attempt to abolish
the
traditional Mass which was 'canonized' by Pope St. Pius V
"in perpetuity" and which Catholics have a right to
use "freely and lawfully", "without any scruple of
conscience or fear of incurring any penalty, judgment,
or censure".
* The Church always taught that tradition should be
held on to - but under Pope Paul VI defenders of
tradition were insulted and persecuted.
* Catholics did not ask to be stripped of their
Catholic heritage - it was imposed on them.
* The 'frenzy of changes' under his pontificate were
unprecedented in the two thousand year history of the
Church, and arguably morphed the Church into 'the
church of Pope Paul VI'.
* Pope Paul's 1960's
Novus Ordo Mass includes changes that parallel those made by enemies of the Church in previous
centuries (alterations that were implemented intentionally to
destroy the faith of Catholics). Note that Paul VI's
Mass, like Luther's reforms, stripped the liturgy of
reverence towards the Holy Eucharist and references to
sacrifice. Recall that Luther said that the
devil
spoke against the (traditional) Mass. It is obviously not advisable to follow Satan's preferences!
* The changes imposed on Catholics caused great
suffering for many - but it didn't seem to matter.
* The changes implemented under Paul VI were 'praised
by
Protestants, criticized by eminent members of the
Catholic Church's hierarchy' - yet the criticisms, despite
being valid, didn't seem to matter. As some have
claimed, Paul VI's
Novus Ordo Mass 'is virtually
indistinguishable from any High Church Protestant
worship service'. That should be problematic for true
Catholics.
* Pope Paul VI and others instrumental in the plethora
of changes had taken the
Oath Against Modernism, in
which they promised and swore, among other things
to...
"sincerely hold that the doctrine of faith was handed
down to us from the apostles through the orthodox
Fathers in exactly the same meaning and always in the
same purport. Therefore, I entirely reject the
heretical misrepresentation that dogmas evolve and
change from one meaning to another different from the
one which the Church held previously"
An oath which notes that...
"dogma may [not] be tailored according to what seems
better and more suited to the culture of each age;
rather, that the absolute and immutable truth preached
by the apostles from the beginning may never be
believed to be different, may never be understood in
any other way."
God be the judge whether or not they faithfully kept
their oaths.
*
The Holy Spirit (God) is perfect, and unchanging. He
was guiding the Church for more than 1,900 years
before the Second Vatican Council. Anyone who thinks
the Holy Spirit wants changes that contradict nineteen
centuries of His guidance is terribly deluded.
* The Church should NOT change to please Protestants,
Schismatics, Jews, or others outside her pale. Rather,
she should work to bring them inside her fold (you
don't do this by becoming one of them yourself!).
* Christ's true Church should never become worldly. As
Holy Scripture says...
Jn. 15:18-19 - "If the world hates you, realize that
it hated me first. If you belonged to the world, the
world would love its own; but because you do not
belong to the world, and I have chosen you out of the
world, the world hates you."
Rom. 12:2 - "Do not conform yourselves to this age..."
Jms. 4:4 - "Adulterers! Do you not know that to be a
lover of the world means enmity with God? Therefore,
whoever wants to be a lover of the world makes himself
an enemy of God."
As to Pope Paul VI's leadership and inaction...
* He has been considered a 'weak leader'. For example,
Amerio's celebrated book [Amazon Associates link
here] notes that...
"Paul VI preferred to give speeches and warnings which
recalled people to their duty without condemning them,
made them aware of something without putting them
under an obligation, and gave directions without
insisting that they be followed."
* He himself failed to obey the
Mother of God (as
noted above, he refused to do the consecration of
Russia to the Immaculate Heart of Mary, as requested
by the Blessed Virgin at
Fatima, even though hundreds of bishops implored
him to do it)
* He apparently chose not to intervene when
heretical
mistranslations or catechisms were introduced
* He reportedly only intervened "in very rare
instances"
* When he did make appeals, they were "contradictory
and feeble"
* He effectively renounced his authority by not exercising it. As
Amerio's book [Amazon Associates link
here] states...
"[F]or Paul VI this renunciation of authority did not
mean a renunciation of dogmatic principles, which he
in fact forcibly reaffirmed in his major doctrinal
encyclicals such as Humanae Vitae, on marriage, and
Mysterium Fidei, on the Eucharist. He also asserted
the principle of the plenitude of papal power to
iudicare omnia (to judge all things), referring expressly to the famous bull
Unam sanctam of Boniface VIlI, in a speech made on 22
October 1970: everything is subject to the keys of
Peter. The renunciation simply means that doctrinal
assertions were separated from that exercise of
authority, in the form of commands and sanctions,
which, in the Church's tradition, is designed to
support them."
* He failed to fulfill his duties as the Supreme
Pontiff. Amerio applies Antonio Rosmini's criticism of
Pius IXs political policies, to the religious policies
of Paul VI...
"A prince who neither prevents anarchy nor makes any
effort to prevent it, who allows people to do
everything that he declares he does not want done, and
who indirectly supports things that are done against
his expressed wish, does not seem to be fulfilling the
duties which pertain to his principate."
* He 'laid aside' his duty to defend & protect the
faith by suppressing the Index of Forbidden Books
Fans of Pope Paul VI may defend his abdication of
responsibility in various ways. For example, by
asserting that...
* He was trusting in God to right the Church, 'placing
his confidence in the Holy Spirit and Providence'
* He had confidence in
Jesus. As noted in the
above referenced bio...
"Paul VI also worried about the attitude he should
take: 'Many expect energetic and decisive
interventions from the pope. But the pope does not
believe that he should follow any program other than
that of confidence in Jesus Christ; for He will calm
the storm.' To the very end of his papacy, the pope
refused to discipline theologians who professed
theories contrary to the Catholic Faith"
* He had a supposed 'mystical concern to suffer for
the Church, compensating in his flesh for his weakness
in governing the Church'. He opined...
"Perhaps the Lord called me to his service, not
because I had some aptitude, not to govern the Church
and save her from the present difficulties, but to
suffer for the Church and so that it is obviously God
and not another who guides and saves her."
* He 'abandoned himself to Divine Providence'. As his
bio states...
"[T]he sense of abandonment to Divine Providence...was
becoming his normal state of mind"
* He supposedly 'did what he could'. As per his
bio...
"When Jean Guitton met with Paul VI in September, the
pope was sad, nervous, questioning himself with the
passage from the Gospel: 'When the Son of Man returns,
will He still find faith upon the earth?' As if to
reassure himself, the pope had added: 'I have fought
the good fight. I have run the race. I have kept the
Faith. ... I have done what I could'"
But none of these excuses/reasons stand up to
scrutiny.
First, he was given the duty to strengthen his
brethren (see Lk. 22:31-32), not leave this for God to
do directly as he sat off to the side. Second, he
definitely did NOT do all he could have done. For
example, he refused the consecration requested by the
Blessed Mother at
Fatima, yet possibly this was the
very remedy provided for evils in the Church by the
Mother of God herself - and it would have been fairly
easy to do, yet he refused.
Furthermore...
* Failure to properly use one's authority is NOT the
same as 'trusting in God's providence', it's a failure
to do one's job.
* Confidence in Jesus does not mean you should not do
what is in your power, especially if it is your solemn
DUTY to do so.
* Paul VI seems to be confusing the value of
suffering
with the requirement to do one's duty.
Is it really confidence in God to choose not to do the
duty imposed upon you and expecting God to take over?
Or is it more like testing/tempting God? Note the second
part of the definition of 'tempting God' according to
the Catholic Dictionary...
"An action by which one endeavours to test some
attribute of God, e.g., to see whether he is
omnipotent, omniscient, merciful, etc. This is a sin
against faith and religion; it is always grave when
accompanied by doubts about one of God's perfections;
if no doubt is present, but one rashly demands the
manifestation of a divine attribute, e.g., the cure of
an illness, the sin against faith and religion is
grave or venial according to the degree of rashness
shown."
Similarly, Holy Scripture speaks unfavorably about
watchmen who fail to warn and 'dogs that do not bark'...
Ezekiel 33:6 - "But if the watchman sees the sword
coming and fails to blow the warning trumpet, so that
the sword comes and takes anyone, I will hold the
watchman responsible for that person's death, even
though that person is taken because of his own sin."
Isaiah: 56:10 - "My watchmen are blind, all of them
unaware; They are all dumb dogs, they cannot bark"
I do not accept 'laissez-faire' (let do or leave
alone/leave it be) Church government. He should have
done his job. As I see it, he was shirking his sacred
responsibilities. He made the mess and then expected
the Holy Spirit to clean it up for him as he sat by
helplessly. Yet, the Pope was literally the only one
on earth with the authority given by God to resolve
the issues. For him to not even try - and throw it all
on God to fix his mess - was a grievous dereliction of
duty, in my opinion.
Further, it is a special kind of irony to wait for the
Holy Spirit to act on one hand, while failing to
recognize that the Holy Spirit HAS been acting for
1,900 years - and simultaneously overthrowing
centuries of the Holy Spirit's own work.
In yet another irony, the weak leader Pope Paul VI
managed somehow to 'find his strength' and authority
when dealing with lovers of tradition (you know, those
who love the Holy Spirit's work over the ages). As his
bio states...
"The fight to preserve the 'Traditional Mass' would be
the focus of Archbishop Lefebvre's actions in the
years to come. Paul VI would never back down."
Besides the fact that there should NEVER have been a
Protestantized new Mass to 'replace' the traditional
Mass, there should have never needed to be a 'fight'
to preserve the Church's traditions. Preserving such
traditions is a responsibility of those in the Church,
especially the Pope. Even the Second Vatican Council
stated...
"Finally, in faithful obedience to tradition, the
sacred Council declares that Holy Mother Church holds
all lawfully recognized rites to be of equal right and
dignity; that she wishes to preserve them in the
future and to foster them in every way."
I'd go out on a limb here and say (or agree with
someone else who may have said it before me) that God
Himself must love
the traditional liturgy since it
developed over the centuries under the guidance of the
Holy Spirit.
Further, Pope Paul VI could say things like...
"No soul of good will who remains strongly attached to
the Church should be able to complain legitimately of
being held at arm's length, or not being heard,
understood, or loved by his pastors"
...yet act in a completely contradictory manner when
dealing with Catholics, like Archbishop Lefebvre, who
loved and defended tradition. Pope Paul VI was 'mild
and indulgent' to those who expressed heresy and
'forceful' against those who defended tradition.
Heresy yes, Catholic tradition no!!!
History shows that Pope Paul VI tried to 'cancel'
Archbishop Lefebvre and his society (the
SSPX - which
was established fully lawfully), to use a term
popularized in the 21st century. Although Pope Paul VI
did NOT excommunicate Lefebvre, he did insult &
marginalize the prelate who staunchly defended
Catholic tradition. According to a publication issued
by a supporter of the SSPX...
"Furthermore, we know that Paul VI attempted to
suppress the Society of Saint Pius X because he
believed the Old Mass to be harmful to the
experiment of Vatican II, and by extension the Church
in the post-conciliar age. Speaking to his close
friend about the SSPX seminary in Switzerland, Paul VI
stated: '[I]f we grant the Mass of St. Pius V to the
Society of St. Pius X, all that we have gained through
Vatican II will be lost.'"
He also tried to 'cancel' the ancient Mass that all
Catholics have a right to according to Pope St. Pius
V. From his bio...
"When Jean Guitton suggested to him that to appease
minds the Mass of Saint Pius V be allowed again in
France, at least 'during a probationary and
provisionary period', Paul VI cried out, 'Never!'"
As a result of Pope Paul VI's actions, some Catholics
were drawn to embrace the troubling theory of
sedevacantism (the belief that the Chair of Peter is
vacant). As stated in Pope Paul VI's
biography...
"Some traditionalists went well beyond the position of
Archbishop Lefebvre. For example, Fr Noël Barbara
(1910-2002), a French priest and theologian, dedicated
an entire issue of his review Forts dans la Foi (Strong in the Faith) to a
demonstration that Paul VI is a 'heretic, schismatic,
and apostate,' sent it to all the cardinals and
patriarchs of the Church, and on November 19, 1976, in
Rome, held a press conference which attracted
widespread notice. Another movement began to appear:
'sedevacantism,' based on the premise that Paul VI
could no longer be considered the legitimate pope."
Sedevacantism aside, strong criticism of Pope Paul
VI's pontificate can be found in various quarters. For
example...
"It is an incontestable fact that never in the history
of the Church had there been so sudden and so
widespread a decomposition of Catholicism. Historians
will certainly record that the Pontificate of Pope
Paul VI proved to be the most disastrous during the
history of the Church." (Davies)
"I replied saying that I thought that the authority of
the Holy See was different to defending the conduct of
the Pope who I consider has done more damage to the
authority of the Holy See than any other Pope for the
last thousand years. If one defends the conduct of
Pope Paul one undermines the authority of the Holy
See." (Houghton-Brown)
To return to Archbishop Lefebvre, the prelate said the
following in his 'Open Letter to Confused
Catholics'...
"How could a Pope, true successor of Peter, assured of
the assistance of the Holy Ghost, preside over the
most vast and extensive destruction of the Church in
her history within so short a space of time, something
that no heresiarch has ever succeeded in doing? One
day this question will have to be answered."
Although I am an SSPX outsider (that's correct, I'm
NOT a member of the SSPX), I have been interested in
the historical events concerning Archbishop Lefebvre &
Pope Paul VI/Vatican II. In fact, I have read several
relevant books, including some by Archbishop Lefebvre.
Let me quote the Archbishop a few more times below...
"It has to be admitted that Paul VI has posed a
serious problem for the consciences of the faithful.
This pontiff has done more harm to the Church than the
French Revolution." (Open Letter to Confused
Catholics)
"What still remains intact of the preconciliar Church?
Where has the self-destruction (as Pope Paul called
it) not been at work? Catechetics, seminaries,
religious congregations, the liturgy of the Mass and
the sacraments, the constitution of the Church, the
concept of the priesthood: liberal ideas have wrought
havoc all round and are carrying the Church far beyond
Protestant ideas, to the amazement of Protestants and
to the reproach of the Orthodox." (A Bishop Speaks)
"My feelings with regard to that are well enough
known, I believe, so that I can express from the
outset the essence of my thoughts: without rejecting
this Council wholesale, I think that it is the
greatest disaster of this century and of all the past
centuries, since the founding of the Church. In this,
I am doing nothing but judging it by its fruits,
making use of the criterion that Our Lord gave us."
(They Have Uncrowned Him)
Which brings us to a proper method for evaluation. We
have to judge based on fruits, the standard given us
for judgment by Our Lord (see Mt. 7:20, 12:33, Lk.
6:44).
With that in mind, here are some ugly truths...
* There have been 'countless disastrous results' of
Paul VI's pontificate. This fact is supported by undeniable statistics.
* Pope Paul VI allowed heresy to spread.
* Pope Paul VI promoted religious indifferentism.
* It is 'impossible' to overstate the destruction from
Pope Paul VI's new Mass (e.g. loss of reverence,
eucharistic abuse, destruction of faith, Church
defections, closed churches, etc.).
* In connection with Pope Paul VI's papacy, there has
been "a virtual torrent of error and dissent".
* Since Pope Paul VI's papacy, there has been a
worldwide 'flight from the priesthood', with many
thousands of priests abandoning their vocations ("the
greatest disaster not only of this century but of any
century since the foundation of the Church" according
to Lefebvre). As Amerio noted...
"All religious communities, great and small, male and
female, contemplative, active or mixed, if not
strictly decimated, have been reduced to a fraction of
their former selves in the course of twenty years."
* Since Pope Paul VI's papacy, thousands of seminaries
have closed. In some areas there is 'near zero'
recruitment of new vocations.
* Since Pope Paul VI's papacy, there have been serious
ruptures with tradition, while
modernism has
flourished in the Church.
* Under Pope Paul VI's watch, many precious & sacred
architectural treasures were destroyed (e.g.
altars, statues). These can never be recovered.
* Since Pope Paul VI's papacy, there has been a great
decline in morality.
* Since Pope Paul's papacy, there has been a major,
negative cultural shift. As Romano stated...
"[I]t is impossible to deny that the shift from a
still largely Christian culture to an entirely
anthropocentric one happened during Pope Paul's reign
and immediately thereafter. Paul VI himself recognized
the crisis both in public speeches and in his private
talks with [his friend Jean] Guitton."
* And many more bad fruits... [Note: Try
here for some examples.]
And no, not all the blame for everything can be laid
at Pope Paul VI's feet. Yet, he does bear a good deal
of responsibility for what has transpired.
In light of the above, what good has his pontificate
accomplished? And what was he canonized for specifically?
Is his canonization not scandalous considering the
fallout tied to his papacy? Yet, as I said above, I do
not believe canonizations are generally infallible,
which I think is aptly covered in the book I mentioned
earlier. And in the case of Pope Paul VI, I DEFINITELY
don't believe his canonization is infallible. To be
honest, it seems like a bad joke (I'm sorry, I think
it would be more polite to say that I have "grave
doubts", but the former comment was more honest)...
* How can a Pope who has 'nearly destroyed' the
Catholic Church be canonized by the Catholic Church?
* How can a Pope who supported false religions and
promoted religious indifferentism be canonized by the
Catholic Church?
* How can a pope who let Modernism (the worst enemy of
the Church) flourish be canonized by the Catholic
Church?
* How can a Pope who deprived priests and the faithful
of the ancient Mass - which they have a perpetual
right to - be canonized?
* How can a Pope who replaced the Church's sacred
liturgy with a Protestantized liturgy be canonized?
* How can a Pope who overthrew Catholic tradition
instead of defending and protecting it be canonized by
the Catholic Church?
* How can a Pope whose actions let the 'smoke of
Satan' into the Church ever be canonized by the
Catholic Church?
* How can a Pope who failed to live up to the duties
of his state in life as the Supreme Pontiff be
canonized by the Church (even if he, on a few
occasions, did some good)?
There is no denying that Pope Paul VI made the Church
"so different from the historical and pre-conciliar
Church". As I see it, he...
* Is responsible for almost unimaginable destruction
in the Church.
* Greatly abused his authority.
* Acted as an enemy of the Church in some respects
(for example by discarding precious treasures,
alienating faithful Catholics, fostering religious
indifferentism and irreverence, allowing heresy to flourish).
* Did what he had no right to do (he may have had the
power, but not the right).
* Made 'probably the most disastrous decision in the
history of the Church'. As Davies states...
"The authorization of a new rite of Mass by Pope Paul
VI in 1969 is an example of such a disastrous
prudential decision, probably the most disastrous made
by any pope in the entire history of the Church."
His was a pontificate of degradation, loss, and
discarded treasures, as symbolized by the ring, tiara,
and banner that he disposed of.

[I am not very artistic, the rough image
above was the best I could do to illustrate my point.
And yes, I know he didn't literally throw the items in
a trash can, but giving 2 of the 3 precious treasures to persons
outside the Church might be worse than throwing
them away - in one case the item falsely signals
episcopal authority that a Protestant layman does not
have (the ring), in another case it has the feel of a
'surrender' to Muslims (the flag)... so I contend that
throwing these two items away might have been
preferable in some respects (not that they should EVER be thrown away!). In the remaining case, it
gives the impression of renouncing - or throwing away
- his authority (the tiara). I, of course, intend no
disrespect to the tiara, ring, or flag. Quite the
opposite. I do, however, believe Pope Paul VI
disrespected these items to some extent, even though I am confident that was not his intention.]
One critic called Pope Paul VI 'the great
destroyer' and compared his papacy to 'dropping an
atomic bomb on the Church'. It is rather difficult to
disagree with that assessment in light of the facts,
is it not?
The controversial Pope Paul VI who is associated with a spirit
of revolution and rupture with the past - despite the
fact that a pope is NOT to make new dogma, but to pass
on the faith of all time - was also cruel.
Yes, he was cruel...
* To faithful Catholics who love tradition.
* To faithful priests who were deprived of their
traditional spirituality and rights.
* To the elderly...
"The plight of the elderly had been emphasized in an
editorial in The Tablet as early as 1965: No one can
be connected with the Catholic press without being
made aware in these last months that, all
unintentionally, a great deal of unhappiness has been
caused to the last people Mother Church would ever
wish to treat unkindly or inconsiderately, the elderly
people who have grown over the years deeply attached
to what they believed was one of the great permanent
realities of their lives, the unchanging Mass."
(Source: The Latin Mass and the Intellectuals)
[Amazon Associates link
here]
* To fathers, mothers and children (e.g. heretical
catechisms, watered down Masses...), and Catholics in
general...
"[T]he maelstrom of confusion that faced those who
were trying desperately to cling on to the Mass of
their heritage and prevent the great traditions of the
Church being cast aside as unwanted goods which had
out-lived their purpose." (Source: The Latin Mass and
the Intellectuals) [Amazon Associates link
here]
* To all Catholics who appreciate beauty &
Catholicity...
"The greatest suffering with which [Pope Paul VI] has
yet visited upon us is the new form of worship which
we are asked to call the Normative Mass. Once again it
is not the almost unbelievable ugliness which
constitutes its main threat, or even its doctrinal
ambiguity, the main trouble is that it is not
recognisably Catholic." (A. Waugh)
* To all who want to save their souls.
The actions of Pope Paul VI and the ramifications of
this 'pastoral council' closed by Pope Paul VI
certainly weren't 'pastoral' to faithful Catholics. I
suppose the irony here is that with the intention of
being 'pastoral', the changes to the Catholic Church
were 'pastoral' (not really) to those outside the
Church while being completely un-pastoral towards
faithful Catholics.
I don't know about you, but I cannot venerate, or
desire to emulate, a 'cruel' saint who had contempt
for Catholic tradition, threw out Catholic treasures
to please heretics, and made it more difficult for
people to save their souls. I don't even think there
could be such a
saint.
As I noted above, his canonization seems politically
motivated (rather than being based on his personal
holiness). And, his alleged 'miracles' for canonization
were questionable. We can't deny truth because the
post-Vatican II Church 'canonized' him. Truth
corresponds to reality and facts. His 'canonization'
corresponds to neither, as I see it. If you support
the opposite conclusion, how do you explain away the
facts above? What, specifically, does his heroic
virtue consist of? In what ways is he a paragon of
exemplary holiness? In what positive, exceptional way
did he benefit Christ's Church? How can you judge his
governance favorably in light of the above facts?
As an ancient papal oath allegedly reads, in part...
"If ever I betray the Tradition received from my
predecessors, God will not be a merciful judge at the
Last Judgment"
If this is truthful, how could Pope Paul VI ever be
considered a saint?
I think that in the name of truth, we have no choice
but to question the canonization of Pope Paul VI (and
the associated 'canonization' of Vatican II).
As for whether or not Paul VI was a bad pope, I
believe the answer is obvious from what appears above.
I think the right question to ask is whether or not he
was the WORST pope ever in the
history of the Church.
I think a case CAN be made that Pope Paul VI was, in
fact, the worst pope in history in terms of his impact
on/damage to the Church and on the faith, an impact
that is still ongoing and shows no sign of abating.
Some might put forth a worthy
argument that Pope Francis was the worst pope due
to his shocking, scandalous actions - he was terrible
indeed (try
here and
here), while prior to Francis' papacy, some might
have proffered the undesirable 'honor' to Pope John
Paul II due to the scandalous actions in his long
reign (which put a 'nice face' to various troubling
events he was involved in - e.g. ecumenical scandals
like Assisi, Koran-kissing). [Note: Try
here for article related to this topic.] But it is a fact that
neither Pope Francis nor Pope John Paul II would have
engaged in the most disturbing aspects of their
papacies without being preceded by Pope Paul VI. Other
bad popes in history seem to me mostly scandalous due
to their personal sins, yet those papacies did not
have such serious ramifications for the Church as the
actions of these post-conciliar popes have had and
continue to have. So, I'd conclude that Pope
Paul VI ultimately may be considered the worst pope in
history... so far.
Sadly, I recently read on the Rorate Caeli blog
that...
"Pope Paul VI is a genuine source of inspiration for
Pope Leo [XIV]"
All I can say is... Oh NO!
Signature:
Pat
Click Link Below To View:
Submit a Comment About this Article ('add post')
Read Comments Regarding this Article (if applicable)
Read Other
User-Submitted Articles
Submit Your Own
Article
More About User-Submitted Articles
Read User-Submitted Posts
Submit Your
Own Post
For Information Related To This Topic Try:
Pope (Topic Page)
Second Vatican Council (Topic Page)
Modernism (Topic Page)
Ecumenism (Topic Page)
Traditional Catholic (Topic Page)
Catholic
History (Topic Page)
Current
Issues (Topic Page)
Vatican View Section
Catholic Life Section
More Information / Resources:
Click Here For Help =>
10,000+ Topics!
Click Here
For Thousands of Quotations From Popes, Saints, Scripture, Etc.
Categorized By Section
Looking For a Great
Catholic Home Page? Try the MCS Daily Digest™ (click here)
Didn't find what you were looking for?
Try Here
We make no guarantees regarding any item herein. By using
this site you indicate agreement to all terms. For terms information,
see "Important Notice" above and click
here.
|